Soft starters and variable frequency drives both tame the violent inrush of starting a motor directly across the line, but they solve different problems. A soft starter only smooths the start; a VFD controls the motor's speed for its whole run. Choosing the wrong one either wastes money or leaves savings on the table.
Starting a motor across the line pulls five to eight times its full-load current and slams full torque into the driveline, because at standstill there is no back EMF to limit current. That inrush sags the supply, trips breakers and snaps belts and couplings. Both devices reduce it, but in different ways.
A soft starter uses thyristors to ramp the voltage up over a few seconds, limiting inrush current and starting torque. Once the motor is up to speed it switches to a bypass contactor and the motor runs at full line voltage and fixed speed. Soft starters are compact and inexpensive, and once bypassed they add no harmonics, but they give no speed control and no energy savings while running.
A variable frequency drive converts the supply to DC and back to an adjustable frequency and voltage, so it controls the motor's speed throughout operation. It provides an inherently soft start plus full speed control, and on variable-torque loads like pumps and fans it saves large amounts of energy, because power falls with the cube of speed. The trade-offs are higher cost, added heat and harmonics, and settings like carrier frequency to get right.
Both devices are now failure points in their own right, with thermal limits and fault codes of their own. A monitoring platform that trends starter and drive temperature, trips and motor current catches a struggling device before it strands a line. Fabrico reads that signal and routes the work automatically. Book a Fabrico demo to see it.
No. A soft starter only reduces voltage during starting and then runs the motor at full line voltage and fixed speed. For speed control you need a VFD.
Yes. Because it ramps frequency and voltage from zero, a VFD inherently provides a soft start in addition to full-speed control.
When the load runs at a fixed full speed and you only need to limit inrush and mechanical shock, a soft starter is cheaper, smaller and adds no running harmonics.
Not while running, because the motor runs at full voltage after bypass. Energy savings on variable-torque loads come from a VFD reducing speed to match demand.
Login
Blog