The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result.
In many factories, this is called "Maintenance."
A bearing seizes. The technician replaces it. Production restarts. Two weeks later, the bearing seizes again. The technician replaces it again.
This cycle destroys profitability. It consumes spare parts, wastes labor, and kills production capacity.
The only way to break the cycle is to stop asking "What broke?" and start asking "Why did it break?"
Root Cause Analysis (RCA) is not just an engineering exercise. It is a financial necessity. It is the difference between a team that fights fires and a team that prevents them.
Here is the strategic guide to mastering RCA tools like the 5 Whys and Fishbone Diagrams in your facility.
1. Symptom vs. Root Cause
Before you start, you must distinguish between the evidence and the cause.
-
The Symptom: Puddle of oil on the floor.
-
The Direct Cause: The seal is leaking.
-
The Root Cause: The shaft is vibrating because the alignment is off.
If you just clean the oil (Symptom) or replace the seal (Direct Cause), the oil will be back tomorrow. You must align the shaft (Root Cause).
2. Tool #1: The 5 Whys (For Quick Wins)
This is the simplest and most powerful tool for 80% of daily failures. It was developed by Toyota. You simply ask "Why?" five times until you hit the actionable root.
Example: The Robot Stopped.
-
Why? The circuit breaker tripped.
-
Why? The motor overheated.
-
Why? There was dust in the cooling fins.
-
Why? The filter on the cabinet was missing.
-
Why (Root Cause)? There is no standard schedule to inspect and replace filters.
The Fix:
If you stopped at #1, you would just reset the breaker. The robot would stop again in an hour.
By going to #5, you implement a weekly "Filter Check" in your maintenance software. The problem is solved forever.
3. Tool #2: The Fishbone Diagram (For Complex Issues)
Sometimes the 5 Whys isn't enough. If a problem has multiple causes (like "Quality Defects"), you need the Fishbone (Ishikawa) Diagram.
This method looks at six categories of influence, often called the 6Ms:
-
Machine: Is the equipment capable? (Calibration, wear).
-
Method: Is the standard process correct? (SOPs).
-
Material: Is the raw material defective?
-
Man (People): Was the operator trained?
-
Measurement: Is the gauge accurate?
-
Mother Nature (Environment): Is it too hot or humid?
The Strategy:
Get a whiteboard. Draw the problem at the head of the fish ("Bad Welds"). Brainstorm potential causes under each of the 6Ms. This forces you to look beyond the obvious.
4. The "Human Error" Trap
When doing RCA, you will often want to stop at "Operator Error."
This is a weak RCA.
You cannot "train" away human error. Humans are imperfect.
Always blame the Process, not the Person.
5. Digitizing the RCA Process
The biggest enemy of RCA is a lack of data.
If you ask "Why did the motor fail?", and the answer is "I don't know, nobody wrote down what happened last time," your analysis fails.
The Fabrico Advantage:
You need a "Digital Memory."
-
Asset History: Before doing an RCA, look at the timeline. Has this machine failed this way before?
-
Evidence: Look at the photos uploaded by the technician during the breakdown. Was the belt loose? Was there debris?
-
Corrective Action: When you find the root cause (e.g., "Add Filter Check"), you can instantly create a recurring Preventive Maintenance (PM) task in the system.
Conclusion: Solving It Once
A good maintenance team fixes machines fast. A world-class maintenance team ensures they don't have to fix them again.
Root Cause Analysis is the discipline of curiosity. It requires time and patience, but the ROI is massive.
By using simple frameworks like the 5 Whys and supporting them with digital data, you turn every breakdown into a lesson that makes your factory stronger.
Login
Blog
