Menu
Book a demo
Plastic to Fiber Packaging on Food Lines: What the Switch Costs Before It Saves

Plastic to Fiber Packaging on Food Lines: What the Switch Costs Before It Saves

Switching a food pack to moulded fiber: the trials, seal settings, held speed and rejects to measure, the EU PPWR dates, and a costed tray line example.
Plastic to Fiber Packaging on Food Lines: What the Switch Costs Before It Saves

In short: Moving a food pack from plastic to moulded fiber or paper changes the material the line was tuned for. Plan for trial weeks at reduced speed, new seal settings (temperature, dwell and pressure), extra start-up rejects after each switch and, until your own data says otherwise, a lower held speed. The OEE baseline you measure on plastic before the switch is the fair test of a supplier's run-speed promise.

  • The EU packaging regulation, (EU) 2025/40, applies from 12 August 2026. For food-contact packs it limits PFAS from that date and sets recyclability and recycled-content rules for plastic parts from 2030 or later. It is not a ban on plastic trays.
  • Two new fiber plants are the case: Paranova's Godmanchester site in the UK, expected to become operational in early November 2026, and Cirkla's moulded fiber plant in Gainesville, Georgia, with production from Q1 2027.
  • Example plant: one chicken tray SKU held at 85% of its plastic speed costs US$61,158 to US$61,771 a year in crew hours, switch time and rejects, about 2.9 cents a tray, before any difference in tray price.

News guide, updated 18 November 2026. Sources are listed at the end.

A switch from a plastic tray to a fiber one (fibre in UK English) is decided in a buying meeting and paid for on the line. Tray suppliers say their new packs run on existing equipment, and both releases in the case below say so in writing. The line finds out at what speed, with which seal settings and with how many rejects. That makes it an OEE question before it is a sustainability one, and it rests on the same discipline as OEE for food and beverage: availability, performance and quality measured by line and shift, so that a change of material shows up as a number instead of an argument. This guide covers what the EU rules ask of a food-contact pack, what changes at the denester and the sealer, two fiber plants coming on stream as the dated case, a costed example for a chicken tray line, and the payback test a fiber pack has to pass.

What the EU packaging rules ask of a food-contact pack

Regulation (EU) 2025/40 on packaging and packaging waste, the PPWR, was published in the Official Journal on 22 January 2025 and, under its Article 71, applies from 12 August 2026. It repeals Directive 94/62/EC. For a food plant it reads best as a set of separate obligations, each with its own scope and its own date, rather than as a verdict on plastic. The ones that touch a tray, a punnet or a lidding film are these.

ObligationArticleApplies fromScope and conditionsWhat it means for a fiber switch
PFAS limits: 25 ppb for any one PFAS and 250 ppb for the sum (targeted analysis, polymeric PFAS excluded), 50 ppm for PFAS including polymeric5(5)12 August 2026Food-contact packaging placed on the EU market; compliance shown in the technical documentation (Article 5(6))A fiber tray's grease or moisture barrier has to test under these limits now, not in 2030
Recyclable within performance grades A, B or C6(3)1 January 2030, or 24 months after the design-for-recycling delegated acts, whichever is laterAll packaging, except the cases in Article 6(11), which include contact-sensitive packaging for infant formula, baby food and food for special medical purposesPlastic and fiber packs both need a grade; a fiber pack is not exempt by being fiber
Recycled at scale6(2)(b)1 January 2035, or five years after the implementing acts, whichever is laterCollected, sorted and recycled at scale on the method the implementing acts setThe grade depends on what collection and recycling really handle
Recyclable within grades A or B only6(3)1 January 2038As aboveGrade C designs have a fixed end date
Recycled content in each plastic part: 10% for contact-sensitive packaging of plastics other than PET, 30% where PET is the major component7(1)1 January 2030, or three years after the implementing act on calculation, whichever is laterAn average per manufacturing plant and year; not for compostable plastic packaging or a plastic part under 5% of the total weight of the whole packaging unit (Article 7(4) and 7(5)(b))A liner or lidding film on a fiber tray is a plastic part, and its weight share decides whether a target applies
Recycled content rises to 25% (other plastics) and 50% (PET) for contact-sensitive packaging7(2)1 January 2040Same exceptionsThe plastic tray's own path gets steeper after 2030
Restricted formats in Annex V25(1)1 January 2030Six named formats, including single-use plastic packaging for less than 1.5 kg of pre-packed fresh fruit and vegetables (Member States may exempt where there is a demonstrated need) and single-use plastic for food consumed inside HORECA premisesA grape punnet sold in the EU is in scope; a retail meat or poultry tray is not among the six formats

Source: the EUR-Lex text of Regulation (EU) 2025/40, as summarised here. Two conditions sit under the table. First, the 2030 dates move later if the Commission's delegated and implementing acts arrive late, because each article says "whichever is the latest". Second, Article 7(12) asks the Commission to assess, by 1 January 2028, whether specific plastic packaging needs derogations from the 10% target for contact-sensitive plastics other than PET and from the 35% target for other plastic packaging.

The same 5% line appears twice, and it matters for a lined fiber tray. Article 7(5)(b) takes any plastic part under 5% of the total weight of the whole packaging unit out of the recycled-content targets. Article 3 defines composite packaging as two or more materials that cannot be separated by hand, unless one of them is an insignificant part and in any event no more than 5% of the total mass of the packaging unit (labels, varnishes, inks and adhesives aside). A fiber tray with a plastic liner and a plastic lidding film therefore has two plastic parts to weigh, and the liner's grams belong on the specification, not in a footnote.

PFAS is a question to put to a fiber supplier in particular, because grease resistance on paper has been one of its food-contact uses. The US Food and Drug Administration's page on authorized uses of PFAS in food contact describes grease-proofers as substances applied to paper and paperboard to stop grease or oil leaking. In February 2024 the agency announced that PFAS grease-proofing substances were no longer being sold into the US market, and a Federal Register notice in January 2025 declared the 35 food contact notifications for those uses no longer effective. For a pack sold in the EU, Article 5(5) puts numeric limits on the same chemistry from 12 August 2026. Ask a fiber supplier for test results against those three limits before the first trial pallet arrives.

What the EU rule asks, and whenRegulation (EU) 2025/40, food-contact packs12 Aug 2026PFAS limits, food-contact packs1 Jan 2030*Recyclable: grade A, B or C1 Jan 2030*Recycled content in plastic parts1 Jan 2030Annex V formats restricted1 Jan 2035*Recycled at scale1 Jan 2038Grades A or B only1 Jan 2040Higher recycled content* or later, if the Commission's acts come late25 ppbany one PFASfrom Aug 202610%recycled innon-PET parts5%line for aplastic partThe rule sets the date.Your baseline sets the cost.
The obligations of Regulation (EU) 2025/40 that touch a food-contact pack, with the date each applies from, as read on EUR-Lex: PFAS limits from 12 August 2026; recyclability grades A, B or C and recycled content in plastic parts from 2030; recycled at scale from 2035; grades A or B only from 2038; higher recycled content from 2040. Dates marked with an asterisk move later if the Commission's acts arrive late; sources are listed at the end.

What changes at the denester, the sealer and the checkweigher

A tray sealer set up for a plastic tray has a seal plate temperature, a dwell time, a sealing pressure, a gas flush and a cycle rate that together give a tight seal at speed. A fiber tray changes the surface the lidding film has to bond to and the way trays come off the stack. Two peer-reviewed studies from LUT University in Finland show where the differences sit.

Leminen and colleagues (BioResources, 2017) sealed press-formed paperboard trays with a lidding film at 190 °C and a 2.5-second sealing time, at pressures of 4, 6 and 10 bar (1.8, 2.7 and 4.5 N/mm²), under a gas mix of 70% nitrogen and 30% carbon dioxide. They describe 6 bar as the industrial standard. Raising the pressure lowered the oxygen content inside the packs for every tray they tested, but a high pressure "was not enough to achieve a leakproof seal" when tray quality was poor. The cause they name is the irregular geometry of folded creases in the tray flange, and they cite earlier work that set a pressure above 1.8 N/mm² as the condition for a leakproof seal where single creases are up to 150 µm deep. The plant lesson: on a fiber tray, the flange the supplier delivers sets the seal as much as the sealer does, so incoming tray quality becomes a line variable.

Merabtene and colleagues (BioResources, 2022) compared a polyethylene-coated paper with an oriented polypropylene and polyethylene laminate and ran both on an industrial vertical form fill seal machine. In laboratory seal tests at a 2-second dwell, the first observable seal came at 90 °C for the paper and 100 °C for the film. The paper's sealing window ran up to 220 °C before it turned brown, while the film shrank at 140 °C. In the production runs, though, the paper showed wrinkling, web buckling, friction in the forming tubes and pouch airtightness problems. A wider sealing window in the lab did not mean the machine ran the paper as it ran plastic. That study is on a bag machine, not a tray sealer; on a tray line, by inference, the matching handling points are the denester and the tray infeed, and that handling problems show up as stops and rejects long before they show up as a failed lab seal.

Machine areaWhat can change with a fiber trayWhat to log during the trial
Denester and tray infeedTrays can nest and separate differently; a torn or misfed tray stops the line or leaves an empty pocketMisfeeds and double picks as their own stop reasons, with counts per shift
Seal plate: temperature, dwell, pressureNew settings for the fiber surface; the plastic lidding film keeps its own upper limitThe settings used at each speed step, and seal failures per shift
Tray flangeCreases in the flange can leak whatever the pressure (Leminen and colleagues)Rejects coded by cause: flange, film, product on the seal area
Gas flush and residual oxygenA leaking seal shows as oxygen inside the pack (Leminen and colleagues measured it)Residual oxygen checks per shift, from the lab or a headspace analyser
Cycle rateA longer dwell is time inside each cycle, so cycles a minute fall unless another step gets shorterCycles a minute per shift against the plastic rate
Checkweigher and case packingA tray of a different weight needs a new tare; a different tray depth or stiffness can change case packingWhen the tare was changed, and case-packer stops by reason

In OEE terms this lands in two places. A slower cycle is performance loss, and short stops at the denester are performance loss too unless they are long enough to count as downtime; the difference between them is set out in reduced speed loss vs minor stops. Short stops at the infeed are the pattern described in micro-stops on packing lines: each one lasts seconds, so they show only when they are counted. For the sealer itself, the loss structure is laid out in tray sealer OEE.

Case: two fiber packaging plants coming on stream, November 2026

The supply side of the switch is being built now. Both plants below were announced by their owners in 2026, and each company has made a claim in writing about how its packs run on customers' lines. Dates are labelled by what they are.

Paranova, Godmanchester, Cambridgeshire, UK (release dated 27 July 2026)

Paranova Print and Packaging's release of 27 July 2026 sets out £20 million over five years for fibre-based packaging, starting with £6 million for a purpose-built board facility of 98,000 sq ft in Godmanchester, with a further £14 million planned for press and finishing equipment and an automated logistics system. It will be the company's fourth fibre-based facility in the UK, making paperboard, carton and sleeve products and fibre-based packaging for fresh produce, convenience and food-to-go customers, with a headcount of 150 once fully operational. The first machines were scheduled to arrive in early September, "with the facility expected to become operational in early November." The new press is described as "designed to support shorter run lengths, faster turnaround, reduced stockholding". This update found no later Paranova release confirming the start.

A second Paranova release, dated 16 September 2026, shows the switch at a packer. With the produce supplier AMFresh, Paranova launched around one million FibreFresh HeatSeal Punnets for BOOMBITES grapes, sold in M&S, Tesco and Ocado. The punnet was "developed as an alternative to traditional plastic formats", and the release says it delivers "excellent machinability and compatibility with existing packing lines."

  • A heat-seal punnet is a sealer setting. The FibreFresh punnet is closed by heat sealing, so the packer's seal temperature, dwell and pressure are what make or break it. "Compatibility with existing packing lines" is the supplier's statement; the packer's own cycles a minute and seal rejects, measured against its plastic punnet, are the proof.
  • Shorter run lengths upstream mean more pack changes downstream. An inference from the release: a press built for shorter runs and faster turnaround lets a packer order more artwork and format variants in smaller lots. Each new lot is a pack change on the filling line, so plan first-off approval after a changeover for each one, and log the board lot against the run.
  • A new site is a new source. With first machines due in early September and operation expected in early November, the first Godmanchester lots come from a plant in its first months. Treat packs from a new plant as a new material to qualify: rerun a short trial on one line against the existing baseline when the source changes, even if the specification is unchanged.

Cirkla, Gainesville, Georgia, US (release dated 18 August 2026)

Cirkla's release of 18 August 2026 announces a moulded fiber packaging plant at the Gainesville 85 Business Center in Hall County, "with production commencing Q1 2027", which is expected to employ over 100 people at full capacity. Cirkla describes itself as the company behind fiber MAP trays "with patented liner technology", cites adoption by protein processors and national grocery retailers, and says the trays were "validated on platforms covering the majority of the US protein processor installed base." Its CEO says its manufacturing in India "runs at scale". The Georgia Department of Economic Development's release of 17 August 2026 puts the investment at more than US$5 million, says the site will support the full portfolio of moulded fiber products including MAP and overwrap trays, and expects approximately 140 new jobs in Hall County over the next three years. The two job figures measure different things (people at full capacity, jobs over three years), so both are given here as each release states them.

A later Cirkla release, dated 12 October 2026, issued jointly with a label and packaging printer and a tray-sealer brand, describes a resealable fiber tray for fresh protein, produce and ready meals. It says the tray was "tested and validated on all major tray sealers in the U.S. market", "with no capital investment or line changes required", and that it reduces plastic waste by up to 90%. The release does not say what the 90% is measured against, and it gives no line speeds. It repeats the Q1 2027 start for Gainesville.

  • "Validated on a platform" is not a held speed. A tray that seals on your sealer model has passed the first test, not the one that pays. Ask for the cycles a minute, the seal settings, the number of trays and the reject rate behind the validation, and then hold the supplier to the speed your own baseline shows for the plastic tray it replaces.
  • "No line changes required" needs a definition. A new seal temperature, a longer dwell or a new denester setting is a line change on the shop floor even if no capital is spent. Write down what the supplier means by it before the trial, and record every setting changed during it.
  • The liner is a specification line. A patented liner is a plastic part. Its weight share against the whole pack decides how the pack is treated under the PPWR's 5% rules for packs sold in the EU, and under the UK fee rules covered below. Ask for its grams.
  • The source changes in Q1 2027. Until Gainesville produces, the release names India as where Cirkla's manufacturing runs at scale. A processor that trials trays now and buys from Georgia later should repeat a short trial when the source changes, against the same plastic baseline.
Paranova, Godmanchester, UKCirkla, Gainesville, Georgia, US
Source and dateCompany release, 27 July 2026Company release, 18 August 2026; state release, 17 August 2026
Money£6 million first phase of £20 million over five yearsMore than US$5 million (state release)
StartOperational in early November 2026, as expected in the releaseProduction from Q1 2027
ProductsPaperboard, carton, sleeve and fibre-based packaging for fresh produce, convenience and food-to-goMoulded fiber MAP and overwrap trays
People150 once fully operationalOver 100 at full capacity (company); approximately 140 over three years (state)
What the releases say about customers' linesHeat-seal punnet with "compatibility with existing packing lines" (16 September 2026)"No capital investment or line changes required" (12 October 2026)
First check for a food packerSeal settings and rejects on the punnet, against the plastic punnetHeld cycles a minute on your sealer, and the liner's grams

The next case will be added under this one, with its date in the heading.

Worked example: one chicken tray SKU moves to moulded fiber

Example plant. Every operating figure in this section is Example data; the wage, the tray contents value and the margin are sourced. The plant is hypothetical, and the sums are not an estimate for any company in the case.

  • The line: one tray-sealing line packs fresh boneless chicken breast in 1.5 lb MAP trays, 1.5 x 0.45359237 = 0.6804 kg: denester, loading, a tray sealer with gas flush, checkweigher, labeller and case packing. Seven people work each shift.
  • The rate: on the plastic tray the sealer runs 13 cycles a minute with 4 trays a cycle, so 13 x 4 x 60 = 3,120 trays an hour is the ideal rate.
  • The SKU: 42,000 good trays a week for 50 production weeks, 2,100,000 trays a year. It runs once a day between plastic SKUs, so the line makes 10 switches a week into or out of it.
  • The plastic baseline: four weeks on all shifts before the switch gave availability 0.87, performance 0.92 and quality 0.986. OEE = 0.87 x 0.92 x 0.986 = 0.7891944, or 78.9%. Good trays per planned hour: 3,120 x 0.7891944 = 2,462.29. Hours a week for the SKU: 42,000 / 2,462.29 = 17.06.
  • The wage: the BLS series for average hourly earnings of production and nonsupervisory employees in animal slaughtering and processing reads US$22.83 for August 2026 and US$22.46 for September 2026 (preliminary). Earnings only, before benefits and any overtime premium, so the money is a floor.
  • The tray contents: UN Comtrade records 2025 US exports of fresh or chilled chicken cuts and offal (HS 0207.13) at US$987,504,417 (FOB) for 673,578,147 kg, US$1.4661 a kg (value divided by weight). A tray holds 0.6804 x 1.4661 = US$0.9975 of chicken at that value. It is a floor for a breast fillet tray, because the export average includes lower-value cuts and offal; for comparison, the BLS average retail price for boneless chicken breast was US$4.099 a lb in October 2026.

Step 1: three trial weeks at 70% of the plastic speed. Performance falls to 0.92 x 0.70 = 0.644 and running quality to 0.962 while settings are found; availability stays at 0.87, because switch time is priced in Step 3. OEE = 0.87 x 0.644 x 0.962 = 0.53898936, or 53.9%. Good trays per planned hour: 3,120 x 0.53898936 = 1,681.65. Hours a week: 42,000 / 1,681.65 = 24.98, which is 24.98 minus 17.06 = 7.92 more than on plastic. Crew hours: 7.92 x 7 x 3 = 166.32. At the two wages: 166.32 x 22.46 = US$3,735.55 to 166.32 x 22.83 = US$3,797.09.

Step 2: the held speed for the other 47 weeks. With settings fixed, the line holds 85% of its plastic speed: performance 0.92 x 0.85 = 0.782, running quality 0.978, availability 0.87. OEE = 0.87 x 0.782 x 0.978 = 0.66537252, or 66.5%. Good trays per planned hour: 3,120 x 0.66537252 = 2,075.96. Hours a week: 42,000 / 2,075.96 = 20.23, so 20.23 minus 17.06 = 3.17 more. Crew hours: 3.17 x 7 x 47 = 1,042.93, which is 1,042.93 x 22.46 = US$23,424.21 to 1,042.93 x 22.83 = US$23,810.09.

Step 3: the time each switch adds. A switch into or out of the fiber SKU takes 8 minutes longer than a switch between two plastic SKUs, while the seal plate reaches its new temperature and the denester is reset. Over the year: 10 x 8 x 50 = 4,000 line minutes, and with seven people 28,000 crew minutes, or 466.67 crew hours: 466.67 x 22.46 = US$10,481.41 to 466.67 x 22.83 = US$10,654.08. The loss belongs to changeover time, so it has to be logged as part of the switch, not left to blur into the first minutes of the run.

Step 4: the extra start-up rejects after each switch. A plastic-to-plastic switch makes 36 rejects before the seals settle. A switch into or out of fiber makes 150 in the trial weeks and 84 once settings are fixed, so 114 and then 48 extra a switch. Trial weeks: 10 x 114 x 3 = 3,420 trays. The other 47 weeks: 10 x 48 x 47 = 22,560 trays. In this Example plant a tray that fails the seal check after gas flush is not repacked, so its contents are lost: 25,980 x 0.9975 = US$25,915.05. The line also has to make the trays again: 3,420 / 1,681.65 = 2.03 hours plus 22,560 / 2,075.96 = 10.87 hours, 12.90 hours in all, or 12.90 x 7 = 90.30 crew hours: 90.30 x 22.46 = US$2,028.14 to 90.30 x 22.83 = US$2,061.55. Whether these trays count as quality loss or start-up loss is a definition choice; what matters is that they are counted per switch.

Step 5: year one. US$3,735.55 + 23,424.21 + 10,481.41 + 25,915.05 + 2,028.14 = US$65,584.36, to US$3,797.09 + 23,810.09 + 10,654.08 + 25,915.05 + 2,061.55 = US$66,237.86.

Step 6: a full year after the trials. Speed gap: 3.17 x 7 x 50 = 1,109.50 crew hours, US$24,919.37 to US$25,329.89. Switch time: US$10,481.41 to US$10,654.08. Rejects: 10 x 48 x 50 = 24,000 trays, 24,000 x 0.9975 = US$23,940.00 of contents, plus 24,000 / 2,075.96 = 11.56 hours to remake them, 80.92 crew hours, US$1,817.46 to US$1,847.40. Total: US$24,919.37 + 10,481.41 + 23,940.00 + 1,817.46 = US$61,158.24, to US$25,329.89 + 10,654.08 + 23,940.00 + 1,847.40 = US$61,771.37 a year, or 61,158.24 / 2,100,000 = 2.91 cents to 61,771.37 / 2,100,000 = 2.94 cents a tray.

Step 7: if the line has no spare hours. The sums above assume the crew can work 3.17 more hours a week. If the line is sold out, the SKU keeps its 17.06 hours and makes 17.06 x 2,075.96 = 35,415.88, or 35,416 trays, 6,584 fewer than demand, a 15.7% shortfall. Those trays are lost sales: 6,584 x 0.9975 = US$6,567.54 a week of chicken at the export value. At the 23.23% gross margin that NYU Stern's margin data (January 2026) gives for US food processing, the lost contribution is at least 6,567.54 x 0.2323 = US$1,525.64 a week, or US$76,282.00 over 50 weeks, for the speed gap alone. Gross margin understates contribution, because cost of goods also carries fixed plant costs, so this too is a floor.

Hours a week to pack 42,000 traysExample plant, one chicken tray SKUPlastic baseline: 17.06 h, OEE 78.9%Fiber trial, 70% speed: 24.98 h, 53.9%Fiber held at 85%: 20.23 h, OEE 66.5%Fiber held at 95%: 18.10 h, OEE 74.4%Dashed line: the plastic hours.Gap: +7.92 h, +3.17 h and +1.04 h a week.
Example data. Weekly line hours for one SKU: plastic 17.06 h (OEE 78.9%), fiber trial at 70% speed 24.98 h (53.9%), fiber held at 85% 20.23 h (66.5%) and at 95% 18.10 h (74.4%), from the OEE factors in the worked example.

The gap is a speed question more than a tray question. In the same example, a fiber tray held at 90% of the plastic speed runs at 0.87 x 0.828 x 0.978 = 0.70451208, makes 3,120 x 0.70451208 = 2,198.08 good trays an hour, needs 42,000 / 2,198.08 = 19.11 hours a week and costs (19.11 minus 17.06) x 7 x 50 = 2.05 x 7 x 50 = 717.50 crew hours, US$16,115.05 to US$16,380.53 a year in speed gap. At 95%: 0.87 x 0.874 x 0.978 = 0.74365164, 3,120 x 0.74365164 = 2,320.19 trays an hour, 42,000 / 2,320.19 = 18.10 hours, and 1.04 x 7 x 50 = 364.00 crew hours, US$8,175.44 to US$8,310.12. Moving from 85% to 95% held speed is worth US$16,743.93 to US$17,019.77 a year on one SKU.

Book a demo and see OEE and losses per line and shift.

The payback test: what a fiber tray has to earn

The worked example gives a fiber SKU a price tag on the line: 2.91 to 2.94 cents a tray in a year after the trials, at 85% held speed and with spare hours, and more if the line is sold out. The switch pays back when what the fiber tray earns per tray is larger than that, after any difference in the purchase price of the trays themselves, which this example does not price. Three things can earn it:

  1. A price or a listing. A retailer that pays more for the fiber pack, or keeps a listing that would otherwise be lost. Only the commercial team can put a number on it, and it should be per tray, so it can sit next to the line cost.
  2. A compliance cost avoided. A fee or an obligation the plastic pack carries and the fiber pack does not.
  3. Speed recovered. Every point of held speed the line wins back lowers the bar. In the example, holding 95% instead of 85% cuts the speed-gap cost from US$24,919.37 to US$8,175.44 a year at the September wage.

The UK shows what a compliance value looks like in a published schedule, and how the liner can reverse it. Under UK packaging extended producer responsibility, large producers pay waste disposal fees per tonne of household packaging by material. PackUK's illustrative fees for 2026 to 2027 (updated 19 December 2025) give amber-rated fees of £455 a tonne for plastic, £210 for paper and board and £525 for fibre-based composite; the page warns that they are likely to change significantly. The government's reporting guidance for large producers (last updated 2 November 2026) says a component of paper or board with plastic layers that cannot be separated by hand is fibre-based composite when the plastic layers are more than 5% of the packaging material by mass, and paper or card at 5% or less.

Tray (Example data)UK classAmber fee, 2026 to 2027 (illustrative)Fee per trayOn 2,100,000 trays
Plastic tray, 21 gPlastic£455 a tonne0.000021 x 455 = £0.009555£20,065.50
Fiber tray, 27 g, liner 1.2 g (4.44%)Paper or card£210 a tonne0.000027 x 210 = £0.005670£11,907.00
Fiber tray, 27 g, liner 1.5 g (5.56%)Fibre-based composite£525 a tonne0.000027 x 525 = £0.014175£29,767.50

The lidding film is left out because it is the same on both trays in this example. If the example's trays were sold in the UK, then with a 1.2 g liner the fiber tray would save £20,065.50 minus £11,907.00 = £8,158.50 a year in fees. With a 1.5 g liner it would cost £29,767.50 minus £20,065.50 = £9,702.00 more than the plastic tray. Even the saving would cover the example's US$61,158.24 of line cost only at an exchange rate of 61,158.24 / 8,158.50 = 7.50 dollars to the pound. The arithmetic leads to two plain conclusions. The liner's weight can flip a fee saving into a fee cost, and a fee alone does not carry a switch that holds the line at 85% of its plastic speed. The case rests on the price or listing and on how close the line gets to its plastic speed.

Trial, block, redesign or wait: choosing the route

A plant has more than one way to take a fiber pack onto a line. The table puts the routes side by side, with the anchors from the worked example.

RouteChoose it ifCost anchor on this pageWatch for
Staged trial of one SKU on the existing lineThe fiber tray fits the sealer's tooling and the SKU has spare hoursTrial weeks: US$3,735.55 to US$3,797.09 of crew hours, plus 3,420 extra rejects (Example)A trial run only on day shift, or only at one speed step
Block the fiber SKU into fewer, longer runsShelf life and order timing allow fewer runs a weekAt 4 switches a week instead of 10, switch time falls to 4 x 8 x 50 x 7 / 60 = 186.67 crew hours, US$4,192.61 to US$4,261.68, and 14,400 fewer rejected trays save US$14,364.00 of contentsProduct made earlier than the order needs it; freshness dates
Ask the supplier for a tray that holds more speedThe trial shows flange creases or denester misfeeds as the top lossesHeld at 95% instead of 85%: US$16,743.93 to US$17,019.77 a year less speed gap (Example)A redesign resets the trial; rerun it against the same baseline
Move all SKUs on the line to fiber at onceA retailer asks for every SKU, and the sealer can be set once for fiberRemoves the 10 switches a week between materials, but applies the speed gap to every SKUThe baseline for every SKU has to exist before the move
Wait, and keep measuring the plastic baselineNo customer asks yet and the pack's PPWR dates are 2030 or laterNone now; the baseline is what makes the later decision fastPFAS limits already apply from 12 August 2026 to food-contact packs sold in the EU

The second route trades switches for longer runs, which is the balance set out in production run length vs changeovers; on a fresh product, the freshness date sets how far it can go.

Questions to put to the tray supplier and the sealer maker before the first trial pallet:

  • On which sealer model, with which tooling, at how many cycles a minute and on how many trays was the tray validated, and what was the reject rate?
  • What seal temperature, dwell and pressure window does the tray need with the lidding film it will run with, and what is the film's own upper limit?
  • What flange flatness or crease depth does the tray meet, and how is it checked on each lot?
  • How many grams is the liner, and what share is that of the tray and of the whole pack?
  • Which PFAS test results against the Article 5(5) limits come with each lot for packs sold in the EU?
  • Which plant will supply the trays after the trial, and will that change during the contract?
  • Who pays for the trial weeks, the rejects and the extra hours if the agreed speed is not reached?

Running the trial: the baseline before, the evidence after

A fiber trial is a measurement, and it needs the same rigour as any process change. It runs much like a new SKU arriving on the line, so the launch steps in new product introduction on a food line apply; the steps below add what a change of material needs.

  1. Measure the plastic baseline first. Four weeks on the SKU, on every shift: availability, performance, quality, the minutes each switch takes and the rejects in the first minutes after each switch. Without it, any trial result can be called a success.
  2. Keep the plastic rate as the ideal rate. If the fiber SKU gets its own, lower ideal rate in the OEE setup, its OEE looks normal and the speed gap disappears from every report. Keep the plastic rate as the reference for at least the first year, so the gap shows as performance loss that someone owns.
  3. Add fiber-specific stop and reject reasons before day one. Denester misfeed, double pick, torn tray, flange crease, film wrinkle, seal failure at the leak test, residual oxygen out of range. A reason list fixed in advance keeps operators from filing everything under "other".
  4. Step the speed, and record the settings at each step. For example four steps from 70% to 90% of the plastic rate, each long enough to cover every crew, with the seal temperature, dwell and pressure written down at each step.
  5. Count switches, not only hours. Log each switch into and out of the fiber SKU with its minutes and its rejects. In the worked example the switches cost more in a year than the trial weeks did.
  6. Agree the acceptance line in writing. The held speed and the reject rate the fiber SKU must reach, as a share of the plastic baseline, and the date by which it must reach them.
  7. Re-baseline when the source changes. A new tray plant, a new liner or a new board grade is a new material, even with the same part number.

Keep the denester and infeed clean and damaged trays out of the stack during the trial, so that misfeeds measure the tray and not the housekeeping; the routine in 5S and packaging line OEE applies. For rejects, keep the categories inside OEE quality loss, as in quality losses inside OEE, so a seal failure and a flange crease never sit in the same bucket.

Who owns which part of the switch

A material change fails on the parts nobody owned. Give each one a name and a record.

RoleThis weekThis quarterThe record that proves it
Plant managerAsk which SKUs a customer wants in fiber, and by whenApprove the acceptance line: held speed, reject rate, dateThe SKU's OEE on plastic and on fiber, side by side
Production managerStart the four-week plastic baseline on the candidate SKURun the speed steps on every crew and log each switchCycles a minute, switch minutes and start-up rejects by shift
Quality or technical managerAsk for the liner's grams and the PFAS test resultsSet leak and residual oxygen checks for the trial, and the reject codesSeal failures by cause, residual oxygen by shift
Maintenance and engineeringRecord the current seal settings and denester setupWrite the fiber settings into the changeover standardSettings per speed step; stops at the denester and sealer by reason
BuyerAsk which plant will make the trays and from whenPut the agreed speed, and who pays for a shortfall, into the contractSupplier lot and source plant against each trial run

Where line data fits in a packaging change

Every step above needs the same record: what ran on the line, at what speed, with which stops and rejects, by shift and by SKU, from before the switch and after it. Kept on paper or in a spreadsheet, the baseline has to be rebuilt once the argument has started; kept by the line itself, it is there before the trial is planned. OEE software keeps that record per machine and line, and a light MES ties it to each SKU, so the plastic and fiber runs of the same product can be compared hour for hour.

Fabrico is a cloud OEE and light MES platform. It shows OEE and losses by machine, line and shift, with data from the machine's PLC or an IoT device with sensors on the machines you connect, and operators give the reason for a stop at the machine. With the selling price and margin of each SKU entered, losses are priced in money, so the speed gap of a fiber SKU can be read in money per week. On manual stations, AI cameras (an add-on) count output.

Book a demo and see downtime by machine and shift.

What people ask next

Can moulded fiber trays run on an existing tray sealer?

Suppliers say they can. A Cirkla release of 12 October 2026 says its fiber tray was tested and validated on all major US tray sealers with no capital investment or line changes required, and Paranova says its heat-seal punnet is compatible with existing packing lines. Whether it runs at your speed is a separate question. Trial it on every shift and every crew against a plastic baseline, and record the seal temperature, dwell and pressure at each speed step. A 2017 study of press-formed paperboard trays found that creases in the tray flange, not the sealing pressure, decided whether the seal was leakproof.

Does the EU packaging regulation ban plastic food trays?

No. Regulation (EU) 2025/40 applies from 12 August 2026. For food-contact packaging it limits PFAS from that date, requires packaging to be recyclable within grades A, B or C from 1 January 2030 or later, and sets recycled-content targets for plastic parts from 2030 or later. From 1 January 2030 it also restricts six formats listed in Annex V, such as single-use plastic packaging for less than 1.5 kg of pre-packed fresh fruit and vegetables. A retail meat or poultry tray is not one of the six.

How long should a fiber packaging trial run?

No standard sets a length. Run it long enough to cover every crew, several switches into and out of the fiber SKU, and each speed step you want to test, and compare it with a plastic baseline measured the same way. The worked example on this page uses a four-week baseline and three trial weeks.

How much speed do food lines lose when they switch to fiber trays?

None of the sources on this page publishes a figure, so measure your own. The worked example assumes 70% of the plastic speed in the trial weeks and 85% once settings are fixed. In that example each 5 points of held speed between 85% and 95% is worth about US$7,900 to US$9,000 a year in crew hours on one SKU.

Is a lined fiber tray paper or a composite for packaging fees?

It depends on the liner's weight. UK reporting guidance classes a paper or board component with plastic layers that cannot be separated by hand as fibre-based composite when the plastic is more than 5% of its mass, and as paper or card at 5% or less. PackUK's illustrative amber fees for 2026 to 2027 are £210 a tonne for paper and board and £525 for fibre-based composite. In the EU regulation, a material of no more than 5% of the packaging unit's mass does not make a pack composite, and a plastic part under 5% of the unit's weight is outside the recycled-content targets.

Which ideal rate should OEE use for a fiber SKU that runs slower?

Keep the plastic rate as the ideal rate, at least for the first year. If the fiber SKU gets its own lower ideal rate, its OEE looks normal and the speed gap vanishes from the reports. With the plastic rate as the reference, the gap shows as performance loss, which can be priced and given an owner.

Sources

Sources accessed on 18 November 2026. Dates are publication dates where a page gives one; other dates are labelled as what they are.

Track OEE and downtime in real time
See where lines lose time
Book a live demo.
See where lines lose time
See where lines lose time

Real Fabrico tiles, sample data.

By clicking the Accept button, you are giving your consent to the use of cookies when accessing this website and utilizing our services. To learn more about how cookies are used and managed, please refer to our Privacy Policy and Cookies Declaration