Undeclared Allergen Recalls: A Monthly Tracker of What Failed
In short: An undeclared allergen recall pulls food that contains milk, egg, wheat, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, sesame, fish or shellfish without saying so on the label. This tracker sorts each regulator notice by what put the allergen in the pack (the label or pack, an ingredient or component, or cross-contact) and names the plant check that stops each one.
- Of 33 FDA recall events naming a major allergen, reported from 12 August to 4 November 2026, 8 notices name a label or pack failure, 4 name the ingredient that carried the allergen, 2 say the product tested positive and 19 do not say.
- The failure sets the size. A wrong Contains line can run on every pack printed with it: one fish recall covered six lots with best-by dates from 2024 to 2027. A wrong outer label stayed inside one lot of 11,765 units.
- Example plant: a wrong film reel spliced into a cheese and onion chip run puts 7,020 bags on hold, $5,896.80 to $23,306.40. Found by a customer under a date-only code, it is 16,740 bags, $14,061.60 to $55,576.80.
Tracker, updated 16 November 2026. Next update: December 2026. Sources are listed at the end.
Allergen recalls read like one problem: the label did not match the food. On a plant floor they are three different failures, and in this guide each gets its own owner. Artwork and label stock sit with quality and the packaging buyer. Supplier and recipe specifications sit with quality and purchasing. Changeover cleaning and the run order sit with production. This page reads each regulator notice for the failure it states, counts the results, and turns each count into a check a food or beverage plant can run. Where a check depends on knowing which product ran, when the line changed over and when a reel was spliced, it uses the same line record that OEE for food and beverage is built on.
New notices join the counts each month. Older ones stay, so the page builds into a record of what failed, how far each recall reached, and which control would have stopped it.
How this tracker reads a recall notice
The US numbers come from the FDA's own Enforcement Report data for food, searched for a recall reason that contains "undeclared" or "allergen", with report dates from 1 August to 16 November 2026. The data were last updated on 4 November, so the newest report date is 4 November and the oldest is 12 August. The search returns 121 product records. Grouped by recall event, that is 44 events.
Eleven of the 44 are about something other than a major food allergen: colours, sulfites, salt, sugar, aspartame, garlic and onion, and two firms' products with undeclared sildenafil or tadalafil. They stay out of the counts. The other 33 events, with 103 product records, each name at least one of the nine major food allergens that the FDA lists: milk, eggs, fish, crustacean shellfish, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat, soybeans and sesame. Sesame joined the list through the FASTER Act, signed on 23 April 2021 and in effect from 1 January 2023. One event is unusually large: a California distributor recalled 61 bulk products at once, from whole wheat flour and black sesame seeds to mole powders, so 61 of the 103 records belong to it.
Each event goes into one of four groups, by what its reason text says failed. Where the product description adds a detail, such as the allergen line printed on a carton, we use it too.
- Label or pack. The notice names the label, the Contains statement, the language of the label or the outer pack.
- Ingredient or component. The notice names the ingredient or component that carried the allergen.
- Tested positive. The notice says the product tested positive for the allergen.
- Not stated. The notice names the allergen and nothing else.
We do not guess a cause where a notice gives none. Notices from Canada and from Food Standards Australia New Zealand are read the same way, in their own section below.
August to November 2026: 33 US recalls sorted by what failed
Eight notices name a label or pack failure, four name the ingredient or component, two say the product tested positive, and nineteen name only the allergen. Seventeen of the 33 events include at least one Class I record. That fits the FDA's own note in its draft guidance chapter on food allergen programs that undeclared major allergens known to cause fatal reactions are generally classified as Class I recalls. Milk is named in 9 events, egg in 8, soy in 7 and wheat in 6. The FDA's allergy page says that milk is the most common cause of recalls due to undeclared allergens, and this period agrees.
Label or pack: 8 events
| Report date | Firm and product | Allergen | What the notice says failed | Scope in the notice |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 28 Oct 2026 | Trader Joe's: Crispy Rice Milk Chocolate Bar, 3 bars under one outer label, imported from Belgium | Wheat | "Product outer label incorrect; contains wrong allergen ingredients" | 11,765 units, one lot (LT26189), 12 states |
| 14 Oct 2026 | J K Patisserie & Bakery: Lemon Blueberry Loaf | Soy | Soybean oil and soy lecithin in the ingredient statement; soy missing from the Contains statement | 87 units, no codes, NY and NJ |
| 14 Oct 2026 | Freshpoint Central Florida: Cranberry Chicken Salad Wedge, 4.5 oz | Egg | Egg in the ingredients list, missing from the Contains statement | 1,093 units, use-by 3 to 17 Sep 2026, FL and GA |
| 14 Oct 2026 | Queso Palmita: Pastel de Queso (cheese pie), 1.2 lb | Milk | "Undeclared milk, cheese declared" | 20 packages, one batch (PQ-1-0024), Texas |
| 2 Sep 2026 | Lidl US Trading: two Greek style shortbread cookies, 330 g | Wheat, soy, milk, eggs, coconut | Some units reached US stores with only foreign languages on the label | 700 units, one lot (260315), 9 states and DC |
| 12 Aug 2026 | Pack'n Fresh: Hondashi seasoning, 0.25 oz pouches | Fish | "Allergen missing from contains statement: fish"; the carton lists bonito but gives the allergen as soybean | 109,600 units, 6 lots, best-by 21 Sep 2024 to 5 Sep 2027 |
| 12 Aug 2026 | Eunha Fisheries (Korea): frozen flounder and halibut, 2 products | Wheat, soy, sesame | The foreign manufacturer's label left them undeclared | 1,915 units, 3 best-by dates, CA and NJ |
| 12 Aug 2026 | JINA F&C (Korea): aged soybean paste, 9 oz | Fish (anchovy) | The Contains statement leaves out anchovy | 4,153 units, no lot codes, 5 best-by dates in 2027 |
Three lessons sit in these rows, and each depends on a fact from its notice.
- The allergen was on the pack, just not in the Contains line. Soybean oil and soy lecithin on J K Patisserie's loaf, egg on Freshpoint's sandwich wedge, bonito on Pack'n Fresh's carton. A label check that reads the ingredient list against the recipe and stops there would pass all three. Check the Contains line against the recipe's allergen list as a separate step, with its own signature.
- An ingredient name is not a declaration. Queso Palmita's pie declared cheese and was recalled for undeclared milk. US law, 21 U.S.C. 343(w), wants the food source named: in a Contains statement next to the ingredient list, or in brackets after the ingredient, unless the ingredient's own name already says it or the source is named elsewhere in the list. For fish, crustacean shellfish and tree nuts the label must name the species or the type of nut, and JINA's notice duly names the species, anchovy.
- Two imports failed on language. Lidl's cookies reached US shelves with foreign-language labels only, and Eunha's fish carried its maker's own label. The check belongs at receiving: no imported finished pack goes to a store until a person has read its label against the US allergen list.
The Trader Joe's row is the classic pack mix-up: three bars inside an outer label for a different allergen profile. One lot code, LT26189, kept the recall to that lot.
Ingredient or component: 4 events
| Report date | Firm and product | Allergen | Carrier named in the notice | Scope in the notice |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14 Oct 2026 | Saint Francis Apizza: frozen pizzas, 4 varieties, 17 oz | Soy | Soybean oil and soy lecithin | 13,761 units, all best-by dates through 30 Mar 2027, KY and OH |
| 7 Oct 2026 | Pacific Health Sciences: collagen peptide capsules | Crustacean shellfish | Crab shell, the source of the glucosamine sulfate | 395 units, one code (25009CP) |
| 12 Aug 2026 | M.G. Foods: Spicy Breakfast Burrito, 2 brands | Soy | Sausage: complaints of sausage in the burritos, and the sausage contains soy not on the label | 498 burritos, one Fresh Thru date, 8 states |
| 12 Aug 2026 | Big Way: Hot Pot Miso Paste, 1 kg | Milk | Lactose | 65 cases, one lot, two affiliated restaurants |
- Sausage in the burritos. M.G. Foods received complaints of sausage in the burritos, then found that the sausage carried soy the label did not list. The notice does not say whether sausage belonged in that recipe. Either way the check is the same: confirm the component staged at the line against the order's bill of materials before the first unit is filled, because a label can only declare what the recipe says goes in.
- Four pizzas, one date range. Saint Francis recalled all best-by dates through 30 March 2027 across four varieties, 13,761 units. A component that carries soy into every recipe puts every product that used it in scope, back to the day it was first used (our reading; the notice names the soy carriers, not the component). The FDA's draft chapter lists, among the steps for building a label specification, identifying allergenic components in raw materials and ingredients from suppliers, with the example of a spice blend that has a milk-derived component.
- Ingredient names that hide the allergen. Big Way's notice traces its milk to lactose, and Pacific Health Sciences' traces its shellfish to the crab shell behind its glucosamine sulfate. Neither ingredient name says the allergen, so both need the food source in brackets or in the Contains line. Keep each supplier's specification with its allergen list and its source materials, and re-read the label every time a supplier or a specification changes.
Tested positive: 2 events
| Report date | Firm and product | Allergen | What the notice says | Scope in the notice |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 Sep 2026 | Marina Del Rey Foods (Laval, Canada): Frankie's Organic Plant-Based Puffs Vegan Cheddar, 4 oz | Milk | Tested positive for undeclared milk | 322 cases of 12, 2 best-if-used-by dates; terminated 15 Sep 2026 |
| 9 Sep 2026 | Savor Seasonings: Organic Cheddar Type Seasoning, 50 lb bags | Milk | Tested positive for undeclared milk allergen | 10,961 lb, 2 lots, one customer in Canada |
A test finds what a label check cannot: an allergen nobody added on purpose. Neither notice says how the milk got in, whether through shared equipment, a supplier ingredient or a mix-up, and both are Class I. Savor's row is worth reading from the other side. Its seasoning went out in 50 lb bags to one consignee in Canada, a bulk pack that reads like an ingredient for someone else's product (our reading). That is the component case above, seen from the supplier. Both recalls stayed small in codes: two lots at Savor, two dates at Marina Del Rey.
Not stated: 19 events
Nineteen notices name only the allergen. They include the two newest Class I recalls in the period, both reported on 4 November: Oliva on Main's hummus and baba ghanouj for sesame, and GF Blends' gluten-free bread, pizza crust and baking mixes for potential wheat gluten.
| Allergen | Firm, product and scope (report date) |
|---|---|
| Milk | Fayus: pounded yam flour, all batch codes (9 Sep). The Better Bakehouse Snack Company: chocolate dipped cake donuts, 10,602 units, one lot (14 Oct). Ferrero USA: s'mores collection, milk and pecans, 1,488 units sold 7 to 14 Aug 2026 (16 Sep) |
| Egg | Kerry: mac and cheese in 3 lb pouches, 6,970 cases, 3 lots (12 Aug). 529 Commerce: aquafaba powder sold as a vegan replacement, 3,860 units, 2 lots (19 Aug). Blank Slate Creamery: vegan non-dairy frozen dessert sandwiches, 66 units (12 Aug). Jaime's Foods ATX: jalapeno ranch, 102 cases (2 Sep). WFM Purchasing: a cheese cut and priced in store, 21 wheels (30 Sep) |
| Peanuts | Bazzini: dark chocolate coconut almond bites, 1,382,916 pieces, 6 codes (19 Aug). Khong Guan: glutinous rice balls with black sesame filling, 2 products, 124 cases (2 Sep). Quality Dairy Farms: ice cream sandwiches that may be rolled in peanuts visible through the pack, 7 units (23 Sep) |
| Tree nuts | L-Nutra: almond and cocoa spread, hazelnut, cashew and pistachio, 8,529 jars, one lot (16 Sep). Ferrero USA, above (pecans) |
| Wheat | GF Blends: three gluten-free mixes, 4,664 bags, 6 lots (4 Nov). Exotique Foods: gluten-free veggie chips made in Indonesia, 68 cases (16 Sep) |
| Soy | Saratoga Potato Chips: loaded bacon and cheddar chips, 769 cases of 13 bags, 2 dates (21 Oct) |
| Fish | TOJI: collagen milk drink, 820 boxes (7 Oct) |
| Crustacean shellfish | Deano's Pasta: pear and pecorino ravioli, undeclared lobster, 78 lb, 4 lots; the label carried "may contain other allergens" (21 Oct) |
| Sesame | Oliva on Main: hummus and two baba ghanouj products, 158 units, best-by dates 10 to 18 Oct 2026 (4 Nov) |
| Several | El Ruisenor De Mexico: 61 bulk products, 51 of them without a UPC, among them whole wheat flour, black sesame seeds, soybeans, raw in-shell peanuts and dried whole shrimp (28 Oct) |
Two patterns show in the product fields even without a cause. First, free-from products: four of these 19, plus Marina Del Rey's vegan puffs, are sold as gluten-free, vegan or non-dairy, which makes 5 of the 33 events. On those packs the missing allergen is the whole promise, so their supplier checks and changeover cleans deserve the strictest test plan in the plant (our reading). Second, a precautionary line did not save Deano's: its ravioli label said "may contain other allergens" and the recall still named lobster. The FDA's allergy page says advisory statements should not be used as a substitute for good manufacturing practice.
Why a label error recalls months and a mix-up one lot
Read the code fields next to the failure, and the size of each recall stops looking random. The table below is our reading of the notices above.
| Failure | Notice | Codes recalled | What set the size (our reading) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contains line wrong on printed packs | Pack'n Fresh, fish | 6 lots, best-by 21 Sep 2024 to 5 Sep 2027 | The same carton text ran on every lot until it changed |
| Contains line wrong on printed packs | JINA F&C, anchovy | No lot codes; 5 best-by dates across 2027 | Same: the label, not a run, was faulty |
| Label wrong, recall by label | Soup Time, wheat (Canada) | "All codes where wheat is not declared on the label" | The notice scopes it by the label itself, in so many words |
| Component carrying the allergen | Saint Francis Apizza, soy | All best-by dates through 30 Mar 2027 | Every pizza that used the component |
| Outer label mix-up | Trader Joe's, wheat | One lot, LT26189 | The wrong sleeve met one lot |
| Foreign-language label | Lidl US, five allergens | One lot, 260315 | One shipment carried the wrong labels |
| Tested positive | Savor Seasonings, milk | 2 lots | Only the lots that tested positive |
So the first question after an allergen finding is which failure it is, before which hours. Each failure has its own unit of scope:
- Label content error: every pack printed from that artwork or label file, back to the day it was released. The record that limits it is a log of which label version went on which production date.
- Label or pack mix-up: the product made from the moment the wrong label, sleeve or film reached the line to the moment someone caught it. The record that limits it is the time of each label or reel change against the order.
- Cross-contact: the product made after a changeover until the next validated clean. The record that limits it is the time and result of each changeover clean.
Two of those three units are measured in line time. That is where a plant's own run record decides whether a recall is a lot, a day or a quarter. Two sister trackers measure scope in line time too: foreign material recalls, bounded by the interval between detector checks, and Listeria recalls, bounded by the last verified clean. The general method for cutting scope to the proven window is in how to keep a food recall narrow.
Case: Soup Time soups, Canada, October and November 2026
On 16 October 2026 the Government of Canada published recall RA-82810: Soup Time brand French Onion Soup, recalled by Soup Time Alberta Inc. because it contains wheat that is not declared on the label. It is Class 1, filed under wheat and gluten. The notice says the recall was triggered by a consumer complaint and that one reaction was reported. On 29 October it was updated to include additional distribution information; it now lists online, Alberta and British Columbia. The codes recalled are all codes where wheat is not declared on the label.
On 14 November 2026 recall RA-82958 followed from the same firm: Baba's Borscht Soup and Wardy's Bow Valley Beef Barley, also Class 1 and for the same reason, with the same code wording. This time the trigger was CFIA test results, with no reported reactions, and the distribution was online, Alberta and possibly other provinces and territories. The second notice lists the first as a related recall.
Neither notice says how the wheat got into the soups, and we make no claim about it. What the two notices do show, line by line:
- One complaint, then two more products 29 days later. The second recall came from CFIA tests, not from a second complaint. After any undeclared allergen finding, list every product that shares a base, a supplier ingredient or a kettle with the first one, and review or test them before an inspector does.
- "All codes where wheat is not declared on the label." The scope is a label version, not a date or a lot. A plant that logs which label version went on which day can show the first day the corrected label ran, and cut the scope there.
- The distribution changed 13 days later. RA-82810 was updated on 29 October to add distribution information, and today it lists online sales next to two provinces. Keep online orders in the same distribution record as store sales from the first day, so the forward trace is complete when the first notice goes out.
- Class 1 for a soup. The FDA's draft chapter treats a food allergen hazard, in most circumstances, as one with a reasonable probability of serious adverse health consequences, and Canada put all three soups in Class 1. An everyday product does not lower the bar for its label control.
The next case will be added under this one, with its date in the heading.
Canada and Australia, October and November 2026
| Date | Regulator | Product | Allergen | Trigger or detail stated | Codes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14 Nov 2026 | Canada, RA-82958 | Soup Time Baba's Borscht Soup; Wardy's Bow Valley Beef Barley | Wheat (gluten) | CFIA test results | All codes where wheat is not declared on the label |
| 13 Nov 2026 | Canada, RA-82929 | Plantropy Jack'd Up Bites Crispy Protein Bites, Ketchup and Sour Cream and Onion, 40 g and 100 g | Milk | Triggered by the company | 8 codes, one best-before date (2027 DE 21) |
| 26 Oct 2026 | FSANZ | Maruto Nagasaki Castella cake, 238 g | Egg and soy | Not stated; Asian grocery stores in NSW | Best before 25 Jan and 14 Feb 2027 |
| 16 Oct 2026 | Canada, RA-82810 | Soup Time French Onion Soup | Wheat (gluten) | Consumer complaint; one reported reaction | All codes where wheat is not declared on the label |
| 9 Oct 2026 | FSANZ | Nissin Salt and Sesame Oil Noodles Aburasoba, 82 g | Milk | Not stated; Asian grocery stores in Victoria | Best before 8 Dec 2026 |
| 2 Oct 2026 | FSANZ | ASTOR Chocolate Wafer Stick, 150 g | Cashew | Not stated; Asian grocers in NSW and online | Best before "MEI 2027" (May 2027) |
Canada's notices say what triggered each recall (the company, a complaint or a CFIA test), which the FDA data do not. The FSANZ notices give neither a trigger nor a cause. All three FSANZ products were sold through Asian grocery stores, and the wafer's best-before reads "MEI 2027", which the notice renders as May 2027. In the US data, label language is a stated failure in two notices, Lidl's and Eunha's, so a pack written for one market and sold in another is worth its own receiving check.
For scale: the Canadian Food Inspection Agency's recall statistics count 57 allergen incidents out of 185 food recall incidents in fiscal 2025-26, 30.8%. The share was 37.2% in 2021-22 and 33.6% in 2024-25. The agency's glossary describes an allergen hazard as an ingredient such as peanuts, milk or eggs that is not identified, or is incorrectly identified, on the label.
The rules behind each failure
The three groups map onto the rules almost one to one.
The label. Under 21 U.S.C. 343(w), a food other than a raw agricultural commodity that is, or contains an ingredient that bears or contains, a major food allergen must name the food source, either after the word "Contains" next to the ingredient list, in type no smaller than the list, or in brackets after the ingredient. The same paragraph extends the rule to flavourings, colourings and incidental additives that are or contain a major allergen, so a soy lecithin or a milk-derived flavouring needs the same declaration as a main ingredient. The US preventive controls rule, 21 CFR 117.135(c)(2), then requires food allergen controls for two things: protecting food from allergen cross-contact, including during storage, handling and use, and labelling the finished food so that it is not misbranded under that same section 403(w).
Label control in practice. The FDA's draft chapter splits label control into two jobs. Label content: compare each label or printed package with the product's food allergen label specification on receipt, before a new batch of labels is released, or immediately before production. Label management: check visually that the labels brought to the line are the right ones, and confirm the right label is used at the start of production and each time new labels or packages are brought to the line, or continuously with a barcode scanner where that is practical. For labels printed in-house, it also suggests limiting how many people may edit label files. When wrong labels have already been used, the corrective actions it gives as examples are to rework, relabel or repack the food, divert it to animal food or destroy it, and to recall what has entered commerce.
Cross-contact. Part 117 defines allergen cross-contact as the unintentional incorporation of a food allergen into a food. The draft chapter's monitoring examples include recording the date and time of cleaning at a changeover from an allergen-containing product to one without that allergen, and testing swabs, final rinse water or the first product through the line with an allergen test kit. In its worked example, one root cause to look for after a positive test is a complete clean that was not done during an out-of-sequence changeover made to fill an order. Food contaminated that way is adulterated, the chapter says, under section 402(a)(4).
Europe and the UK. The UK text of Regulation 1169/2011, Annex II lists 14 allergens: the US nine, with cereals containing gluten in place of wheat, plus celery, mustard, lupin, molluscs, and sulphur dioxide and sulphites above 10 mg/kg. Article 21 wants the allergen emphasised inside the ingredient list, by font, style or background colour, and keeps "contains" for foods with no ingredient list. A pack built around a US Contains line is not, by that fact, an EU or UK pack.
Worked example: a wrong film reel on a chip line
Example plant. Every operating figure in this section is Example data; the two unit values are sourced.
- The line: kettle chips through a seasoning drum to a bagger that makes 8 oz bags at 54 a minute, 3,240 an hour.
- Today's orders, allergen-free first: sea salt, with no major allergen on its film, from 06:00 to 09:00, 180 minutes or 54 x 180 = 9,720 bags. Then a 30-minute changeover. Then cheese and onion, which contains milk and uses a film whose Contains line says so, from 09:30 to 13:50, 260 minutes or 54 x 260 = 14,040 bags.
- The baseline: the film is checked against the order at each changeover, as a first-off check. A reel spliced in mid-run is not checked, and the unused sea salt reels from the morning stay on the staging rack.
- The error: at 11:40 the cheese and onion reel runs out and the operator splices the next reel from the rack. It is a sea salt reel. From 11:40 to 13:50, cheese and onion chips go into bags whose label does not declare milk: 54 x 130 = 7,020 bags.
The FDA's draft chapter covers both gaps in that baseline: it recommends confirming the label each time new labels or packages are brought to the line, and removing unused packaging from the line after a run.
Two unit values, low and high.
- Low, a trade value. UN Comtrade records US exports under HS 200520 in 2025 at $356,277,622 FOB for 95,990,462 kg, which is $3.7116 a kg (our arithmetic). The US tariff schedule files that code as prepared potatoes, not frozen, and splits it into potato chips, potato granules and other, so this is a value across more than chips. An 8 oz bag holds 0.2268 kg: $3.7116 x 0.2268 = $0.84 a bag.
- High, a shelf price. The BLS US city average price for potato chips was $6.638 per 16 oz in October 2026. Half of that for an 8 oz bag: 6.638 / 2 = $3.319, about $3.32 a bag. A plant's own selling price sits below the shelf.
Both are sales values, not margin, and neither is any named company's price.
| Where the wrong reel is caught | Bags in scope | At $0.84 | At $3.32 | What happens next |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. At the splice, by a check of the reel against the order | A few, rejected; a 5-minute stop (Example data) to change the reel costs 54 x 5 = 270 bags of output | $226.80 of output | $896.40 of output | The line restarts with the right film |
| B. At 13:50, when the reels used are counted against the order | 54 x 130 = 7,020 | $5,896.80 | $23,306.40 | Held: relabel, repack, divert to animal food or destroy |
| C. By a customer after shipping, with only the best-by date on the bag | 54 x 310 = 16,740 | $14,061.60 | $55,576.80 | Recall of every sea salt bag with that date, plus recall costs not priced here |
The sums, step by step:
- A: 270 x $0.84 = $226.80; 270 x $3.32 = $896.40. This is output the line did not make, not product at risk.
- B: 7,020 x $0.84 = $5,896.80; 7,020 x $3.32 = $23,306.40.
- C: the customer holds a bag labelled sea salt. With a date-only code, nobody outside the plant can tell the mislabelled bags from the real sea salt run of the same morning, so the recall covers both: 180 + 130 = 310 minutes, and 54 x 310 = 16,740 bags. 16,740 x $0.84 = $14,061.60; 16,740 x $3.32 = $55,576.80.
Against the realistic baseline, a first-off check at changeover only, a reel check at every splice keeps $5,896.80 to $23,306.40 of product out of a hold on the day it matters, and $14,061.60 to $55,576.80 out of a recall if the error would otherwise reach a shelf. Line and hour in the code would let the same recall be argued down to the 7,020 bags; whether a regulator accepts that is a quality and regulatory call. The loss also shows in OEE. If the 7,020 bags are destroyed, they are rejects in this example's count, and quality for the cheese and onion order falls to 7,020 good bags out of 14,040 made, 50.0%.
Book a demo and see changeovers and losses per line and shift.
One line, three failures: what each puts in scope
The same Example plant, the same two unit values, and the other two failure groups.
| Failure | What goes wrong (Example data) | Bags in scope | At $0.84 | At $3.32 | The check that stops it |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Reel mix-up (label or pack) | Sea salt reel spliced into cheese and onion at 11:40, found at 13:50 | 7,020 | $5,896.80 | $23,306.40 | Check each reel against the order at every splice, not only at changeover |
| Artwork error (label content) | A new cheese and onion film prints a Contains line without milk; found after 6 weeks of 3 orders a week like today's, 260 minutes each | 252,720 | $212,284.80 | $839,030.40 | Compare each new artwork and each film delivery with the allergen label specification before release |
| Cross-contact | A rush order puts a 380-minute sea salt run straight after cheese and onion, out of sequence; the clean is cut short and a test of the first bags finds milk | 20,520 | $17,236.80 | $68,126.40 | A validated clean, allergen-free products run first, a test of the first product through |
The sums: the artwork case is 6 x 3 x 260 = 4,680 minutes of the cheese and onion order, and 54 x 4,680 = 252,720 bags; 252,720 x $0.84 = $212,284.80 and 252,720 x $3.32 = $839,030.40. The cross-contact case is the whole rush order, 54 x 380 = 20,520 bags, because nothing before the next validated clean can be shown to be free of milk; 20,520 x $0.84 = $17,236.80 and 20,520 x $3.32 = $68,126.40.
The ranking is the point. In this example the artwork error costs the most per event because its scope is the time since release, not a run, the same shape as the multi-year best-by range in Pack'n Fresh's notice and Canada's "all codes" wording for Soup Time. A label content check runs once per artwork version and per film delivery and costs no line time, so in this example it protects the most money per check.
Which control to fund first
None of the rules read for this page fixes a frequency or a technology, and the FDA's draft chapter gives the plant flexibility on both, as long as the checks are adequate to make the control work. This table uses the Example plant's numbers as the cost anchor, because no independent price survey for label scanners or vision systems was readable.
| Control | Stops | Run by | What it costs to run | Fund it first if | Questions to settle first |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Label content check against the allergen label specification | Artwork errors, an incomplete Contains line, a missing species name | Quality or regulatory | Desk time per artwork version and delivery; no line time | You change artwork, suppliers or recipes often, or print labels in-house | Who can edit label files? Does the specification list allergens inside components? |
| Label and film check at changeover and at every reel or label change | Reel, sleeve and label mix-ups | Operators, or a scanner or vision system | A short stop per reel change if done by hand; a scanner reads as the film runs | Several SKUs share film widths, label sizes or a staging rack | Does the machine stop on a mismatch, or only alarm? Is each read logged against the order? |
| Supplier and recipe specification control | Undeclared components and sub-ingredients | Quality and purchasing | Paperwork per supplier and per specification change | You buy seasonings, sauces, fillings or blends | Does each specification name allergenic sub-ingredients and source materials? Who is told when a supplier changes a formula? |
| Validated allergen clean and a fixed run order | Cross-contact at changeover | Production and sanitation | Line time per allergen changeover | One line runs allergen and allergen-free SKUs | Is the clean validated by test for each allergen? What happens to the order sequence when a rush order arrives? |
| A dedicated line | Cross-contact for one allergen | Plant management | Capacity: a line that runs one allergen profile | Free-from products, or one allergen in most of the volume | Is there enough volume to load the line? |
Choose the label content check first if your recalls would be scoped by artwork, as in the Pack'n Fresh and Soup Time notices: in the example it guards the largest scope for no line time. Choose reel and label checks at every change if one line packs several allergen profiles from shared film or label stock. Choose specification control first if most of your allergens arrive inside bought components. Choose the validated clean and run order if the same equipment handles allergen and allergen-free products; how to prove a clean works is covered in allergen changeover validation, how to sequence products in an allergen changeover matrix, and when to stop sharing altogether in dedicated vs shared allergen lines.
Label and film verification itself is a separate system: a person with a checklist, a barcode scanner or a vision system that reads the label or film code. For that job, see label code vision vs an OEE camera. Fabrico's AI cameras (an add-on) count output; they do not read labels, film or codes and are not that system.
A plant check for this month
Quality manager
- Pull the live artwork for every SKU that contains a major allergen. Read the Contains line, not only the ingredient list, against the recipe's allergen list, component by component. Three of this period's eight label recalls had the allergen in the list and not in the Contains line.
- For every imported finished product, confirm the label you sell under is in the market's language and names the US allergens, as Lidl's and Eunha's notices show is not a given.
- List every supplier specification for seasonings, sauces, fillings and blends, and mark the ones that do not name allergenic sub-ingredients or source materials, such as lactose or glucosamine. When the problem arrives in a supplier's ingredient lot instead, the Salmonella recalls tracker shows how a receiving plant bounds its share.
Production manager
- Walk the film and label staging rack on one line. Are reels for different allergen profiles stored side by side at the same width? Watch one mid-run reel change and see whether anyone checks the new reel against the order.
- From last week's orders, list each changeover from an allergen product to one without that allergen, and mark any that ran out of sequence to fill an order. Each one is a cross-contact risk the FDA's own example names.
- Log each reel change and each allergen changeover as a timed event on the line record, with the order, so the window in the worked example can be read from the record, not reconstructed. How splice stops show up in the numbers is covered in film splice stops, and the sign-off itself in first-off approval after changeover.
Plant or CI manager, this quarter
- Keep a register of which label version ran on which production days, so an artwork error can be scoped to the day the correction started.
- Run a trace drill on one artwork version: name every date, order and lot that used it, and time how long it takes. A worked format is in the mock recall trace drill.
- Score the five controls in the decision table against the plant's product mix and fund the one that guards the largest scope.
- Decide how allergen holds, relabels and destroyed product count in OEE (this guide counts destroyed bags as rejects), and log allergen changeover cleans as their own stop reason, so their cost sits on the same chart as speed and downtime. OEE software records the run time, stops and counts, and a light MES ties them to each product.
Where the line record helps
Two of the three scopes in this tracker are measured in line time: the minutes between a reel change and its catch, and the run between a changeover and the next validated clean. A plant that records orders, changeovers and stops against the clock can answer "which bags?" from its own record instead of rebuilding the day from memory. The label check, the specification and the allergen test stay with the food safety plan; the line record tells quality which product ran, when the line changed over or stopped, and how many units it made in between. How the two kinds of record differ is covered in HACCP records vs OEE data.
Fabrico is a cloud OEE and light MES platform. It shows OEE and losses by machine, line and shift, from the PLC or a Fabrico IoT device, with the reasons operators add. On manual stations, AI cameras (an add-on) count output.
Book a demo and see downtime per line and shift.
What people ask next
What causes undeclared allergen recalls?
In FDA Enforcement Report data for 12 August to 4 November 2026, 33 recall events named a major food allergen. Eight notices name a label or pack failure, such as a Contains statement missing an allergen, a wrong outer label or a label in the wrong language; four name the ingredient or component that carried the allergen; two say the product tested positive; nineteen name only the allergen. The FDA says milk is the most common cause of recalls due to undeclared allergens.
What is the difference between an undeclared allergen and allergen cross-contact?
An undeclared allergen is an allergen in the food that the label does not name. Cross-contact is one way that happens: the FDA defines allergen cross-contact as the unintentional incorporation of a food allergen into a food, for example from equipment that was not fully cleaned at a changeover. Its draft guidance treats a wrong label as misbranding under section 403(w) and food with cross-contact as adulterated under section 402(a)(4), so the two need different controls: label checks for the first, a validated clean and a fixed run order for the second.
Does a Contains statement have to list every allergen?
US law, 21 U.S.C. 343(w), requires each major food allergen in a food to be named, either in a Contains statement next to the ingredient list or in brackets after the ingredient in the list. In this tracker the FDA recorded two recalls where the allergen was in the ingredient list but missing from the Contains statement, soy on a bakery loaf and egg on a sandwich wedge, and a third where a seasoning carton listed bonito but gave its allergen as soybean only. If you print a Contains line, check it against the recipe as its own step.
How often should labels and packaging film be checked on a line?
The FDA's draft food allergen chapter recommends checking label content against the product's allergen label specification before the labels are used, and confirming the right label is used at the start of production and each time new labels or packages are brought to the line, or continuously with a barcode scanner. In our reading, each new film reel on a bagger is new packaging brought to the line, so a mid-run splice needs the same check as a changeover.
How big is a recall when an allergen label is wrong?
In these notices, a wrong Contains line reached every pack printed with it. One fish recall in this tracker covered six lots with best-by dates from September 2024 to September 2027, and Canada recalled three soups for all codes where wheat is not declared on the label. A wrong outer label stayed inside the lot it met: Trader Joe's recall was one lot of 11,765 units.
Can OEE software prevent an allergen recall?
No. OEE software does not read labels, check film or test for allergens; those jobs belong to the food safety plan, with people, scanners or vision systems, and test kits. What it records is the line's timeline: which product ran, when the line changed over, when it stopped and how many units it made. After a reel mix-up or a cut-short clean, that record answers which order, which minutes and how many bags, instead of a whole day of output.
Sources
Sources accessed on 16 November 2026 unless marked as accessed on another date. Dates are publication dates where a page gives one; other dates are labelled as what they are.
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Enforcement Report data for food (openFDA), recall reason containing undeclared or allergen, report dates 12 August to 4 November 2026, data as of 4 November 2026, accessed 16 November 2026
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Food Allergies, content current as of 11 March 2026, accessed 16 November 2026
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Hazard Analysis and Risk-Based Preventive Controls for Human Food: Draft Guidance for Industry, Chapter 11, Food Allergen Program, draft, published 27 September 2023, accessed 16 November 2026
- Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, 21 U.S. Code 343, Misbranded food, paragraph (w), page undated, accessed 16 November 2026
- Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, 21 CFR 117.135, Preventive controls, page undated, accessed 16 November 2026
- legislation.gov.uk, Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, Annex II, Substances or products causing allergies or intolerances (UK text), adopted 25 October 2011, latest revised text, accessed 16 November 2026
- legislation.gov.uk, Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, Article 21, Labelling of certain substances or products causing allergies or intolerances (UK text), adopted 25 October 2011, latest revised text, accessed 16 November 2026
- Canadian Food Inspection Agency, Statistics: food recall incidents and food recalls, modified 13 August 2026, accessed 16 November 2026
- Government of Canada, Recalls and safety alerts: Soup Time brand French Onion Soup recalled due to undeclared wheat (RA-82810), published 16 October 2026, updated 29 October 2026, accessed 16 November 2026
- Government of Canada, Recalls and safety alerts: Soup Time brand Baba's Borscht Soup and Wardy's Bow Valley Beef Barley recalled due to undeclared wheat (RA-82958), published 14 November 2026, accessed 16 November 2026
- Government of Canada, Recalls and safety alerts: Certain Plantropy brand Jack'd Up Bites Crispy Protein Bites recalled due to undeclared milk (RA-82929), published 13 November 2026, accessed 16 November 2026
- Food Standards Australia New Zealand, Maruto Nagasaki Castella cake 238g recall, issued 26 October 2026, accessed 16 November 2026
- Food Standards Australia New Zealand, Nissin Salt and Sesame Oil Noodles Aburasoba 82g recall, published 9 October 2026, accessed 16 November 2026
- Food Standards Australia New Zealand, ASTOR Chocolate Wafer Stick 150g recall, published 2 October 2026, accessed 16 November 2026
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Average price data, series APU0000718311, potato chips, per 16 oz, U.S. city average, October 2026 data, accessed 16 November 2026
- UN Comtrade, United States trade in HS 200520 (potatoes, prepared or preserved, not frozen), 2025, data year 2025 (no publication date in the API response), accessed 16 November 2026
- U.S. International Trade Commission, Harmonized Tariff Schedule, heading 2005 and subheading 2005.20, current schedule (no date in the API response), accessed 16 November 2026
Related articles
Latest from our blog

Real Fabrico tiles, sample data.



